Skip to content

Geoffrey Cohen and The Temple of Fishballs

13th December


Chats Palace: 42-44 Brooksby’s Walk London E9 6D

£7.50 in advance £10 on the door

Facebook event

Buy Tickets 

fishballs 2

166 BCE. The Greeks have conquered Judea, sacked the temple and set up a range of high-quality saunas in Jerusalem. But young Judeans refused to take this defeat – or the communal baths – lying down. They launched an uprising against the oppressors, led by Mattathias and his sons, Judea’s greatest dynasty – the Maccabees. 


But an equally eminent dynasty was also involved in this epic conflict.


At first Geoffrey Cohen and her disciples had chosen to remain in Babylon – where there were better cafes, no animal sacrifices and if you shluffed in on shabbes morning, no one came round and dragged you to the temple. But when the Maccabees issued their call to arms, Geoffrey instructed her followers to answer it, adding that it ‘sounded like a bit of a jolly’ and ‘it might make them famous’.


And so the group journeyed to the land of their ancestors. Once there, they contributed immensely to the war effort, fighting bravely from the back line and tactically hiding behind trees. For their legendary heroism they earned the name ‘The Beigel Brigade’.  But as victory drew close Geoffrey began to have a change of heart. “Do we really want this temple after all?” she asked her brave army. “And these Greeks – they seem rather civilised, with all their philosophy, democracy and tabbouleh.” “Do we really want to live in a theocracy?” the troops agreed. “Shouldn’t we just pack it all in?”


So the Beigel Brigade returned to the diaspora, and received a hero’s welcome from the people of Pumbedita. A large meal was immediately organised for their return, in which Babylonian dishes such as hummus and pita sat next to Biblical delicacies such as pickles and almond kugel. At the centre of this great feast was an exact replica of the temple, made entirely out of fishballs. It is of this meal that the Book of Jewdas records “On that day swords were turned into breadsticks and cannonballs into gefilte fish”. A great miracle took place that night, as an apparently small pile of beigels turned out to be enough for everyone to have six each. And, most famously, eight candles were lit, one for every gin and tonic that Geoffrey Cohen consumed.


Ever since that day (apart from a few years when everyone forgot), the people of Babylonia marked the festival !الحفلة كبيرة (al-hefle kbeereh) or ‘night of large party’ on the 23rd of Kislev. Or, as Rav Geoffrey taught, ‘on a Saturday night conveniently close to Christmas’. While some reportedly celebrate another, more militaristic Jewish festival a few short days later, we only have vague descriptions of this custom and it cannot be verified whether or not these people are actually Jews at all. 

Live Music including TantzTurkish-Bulgarian-Kurdish-and-more extravaganza from She’koyokh, with beats from DJ Chopped Liver and a special appearance by the Birobizhan Community Orchestra



Beigel Battles

Stephen Pollard Pinata

Philo Semite of the Year

Julie Burchill live in conversation with Harry Styles

How To Break in to JFS: A Talk from Two Former Pupils

Share unto the nationsShare on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on tumblr
Share on reddit

2 thoughts on “Geoffrey Cohen and The Temple of Fishballs”

  1. I’m not coming because the beigel whilst ideal as a form of ammunition bungs up the digestive system, as indeed does matzah. But have a jolly good time and thanks for the invitation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *